Case Analysis - Public Health vs. Privacy Rights, in Neonatal HIV Testing

Dr. Tremblays mooring is basically a classical ethical debate, where the marvel is asked: do the needs of the few, surpass the rights of the many? In this lesson the many is comprised of 37 babies, and their m a nonher(prenominal)s, namelessly tried and true for HIV, and the few is an anonymous bollocks up from the group, suspected of having neonatal HIV. Tremblay hoped to collapse this baby and peddle discussion (as well as adult treatment to the begin), yet in doing so he would botch up the right to anonymity that the other thirty-six mothers and babies are de jure entitled to. At the oddity of the synopsis explaining Dr. Tremblays plight, he has bygone ahead and started to give named tests (breaking the anonymity). In this analysis I am trying to bang whether or non Dr. Tremblay was ethically and legally confirm in his processs by exploitation three tests: 1) the consequentalist/ useful test, 2) the deontological test, and 3) the imperious Courts Three-Pronged Test. The utilitarian test, as follows with utilitarianism, is plum simple: weight the avails and the consequences of Dr. Tremblays fulfil - this includes some(prenominal) probably short-term and semipermanent effects, as well as possible near and removed reaching consequences of such an exploit. Since Dr.

Tremblay is not directly trying to injure anyone, and as a doctor, it is intact to assume that he has elect his profession to help people, his action is first and foremost (in his eyes) to benefit the health of the infected baby. Therefore, I will first figure the benefits of his action(s). Obviously, Dr. Tremblay would be able to assure the infected baby/mother if he is allowed to perform named retests of the thirty-seven babies/mothers. With the named results he will be able to determine which is infected, and maintenance them with treatment. It is... If you want to get a full essay, order it on our website: Orderessay

If you want to get a full information about our service, visit our page: How it works.